Top 10 Best Insurance Brokers in Newcastle, NSW
Updated June 03, 2026
Looking for a reliable insurance broker in Newcastle? We’ve reviewed and ranked the top-rated insurance brokers in Newcastle, NSW based on customer feedback, service quality, and overall reputation. Whether you need coverage comparison, business insurance, or custom policies, these trusted professionals are among the best in your area.
-
Arena Insurance Brokers
02 4067 5203 · 59 Mitchell Rd · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support -
Ausure Horizon Insurance
1300 639 000 · Suite 2 Level 6/384 Hunter St · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support -
Fisher Insurance Pty Ltd
02 4910 4039 · 17 Bolton St · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support
-
FloorInsure
1800 607 204 · 2/97 Scott St · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support -
Ian Jones Insurance Brokers
02 4910 3900 · 97 Scott St · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support -
Markey Insurance & Risk
02 4925 6555 · Lvl 2/47 Darby St · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support -
MGA Insurance Group
02 4918 5000 · 49 Ridley St · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support -
NewSure Insurance Brokers
02 4969 8100 · Level 3/50 Hunter St · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support -
Phoenix Risk Services
1300 609 128 · Suite 3, Level 2/426 King St · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support -
R&M Insurance Brokers
02 4962 4888 · 1st Floor/184 Parry St · Get directions
coverage comparison business insurance custom policies claims support
These insurance brokers represent some of the most trusted and active professionals in Newcastle, NSW.
They provide coverage comparison, business insurance, or custom policies and other related solutions for both residential and commercial clients.
All listings are regularly updated, ensuring that business information, contact details, and service areas remain accurate and current.
Our independent scoring system considers multiple factors — including profile completeness, verified reviews, responsiveness, and local engagement — giving you a fair and transparent way to discover reliable providers nearby.
FAQs about insurance brokers in Newcastle, NSW
How do I find the best insurance broker in Newcastle?
Start by browsing verified listings on this page — each profile includes full contact information, opening hours, and details about services offered. You can compare businesses by their rating, customer feedback, and the completeness of their profiles. Our ranking highlights local providers with a strong reputation, proven experience, and consistent service quality, making it easier for you to choose a trusted insurance broker that meets your needs. If you’re not sure where to start, check a few of the top-rated listings and contact them directly for a quote or consultation.
How are insurance brokers ranked on this page?
All rankings are based on our internal evaluation system, which combines several key factors — including verified status, profile completeness, customer responsiveness, and local reputation. Businesses with accurate NAP information, clear service descriptions, active communication, and consistently positive feedback from clients receive higher visibility in the listings. This ensures that rankings are fair, transparent, and based on measurable quality rather than advertising or paid promotion. Our goal is to help users quickly identify reliable and well-established insurance brokers in Newcastle and surrounding areas.
Do these insurance brokers serve nearby suburbs?
Yes. Most listed businesses operate not only within Newcastle, NSW, but also in surrounding suburbs and regional areas. Each company profile specifies its main service zones, allowing you to find a insurance broker close to your location. If your suburb isn’t listed directly, you can still reach out to nearby providers — many of them cover extended areas or offer mobile services. This flexibility makes it easier to connect with professionals who can come to you when needed.
Can I contact these insurance brokers directly?
Yes, every listing includes direct contact details such as phone numbers, websites, and, in some cases, booking links. You can reach out to businesses for quotes, service inquiries, or scheduling appointments at any time. We encourage users to contact providers through their official websites or phone numbers to confirm availability, pricing, and specific service details. This direct communication helps ensure you get the most accurate information and a faster response from the business you choose.